EIC awards 160 Seals of Excellence to March 2022 Accelerator applicants

Brussels, August 29th 2022
Summary
  • The European Innovation Council awarded 160 Seals of Excellence to applicants from the EIC Accelerator March 2022 cut-off.
  • Recipients' proposals were judged by independent experts to meet EIC quality standards but were not funded because of budget limits.
  • The Seal is a quality label intended to help companies find alternative public or private funding and to let funders rely on Horizon Europe evaluations.
  • Under Horizon Europe the EIC has issued 302 Seals of Excellence in total.
  • The Seal is delivered with evaluation results and can be digitally protected and shared with third party funders with the applicant's consent.

EIC issues 160 Seals of Excellence after March 2022 Accelerator cut-off

On 29 August 2022 the European Innovation Council announced that 160 companies that applied to the EIC Accelerator during the March 2022 cut-off received an EIC Seal of Excellence. Independent evaluators determined that these proposals met the EIC's high quality thresholds but were not selected for funding only because the available budget was exhausted. The Seal is intended as a recognised quality label to help companies access alternative funding sources and to allow other funders to rely on the Horizon Europe evaluation process when making their own decisions.

The announcement repeats an increasingly familiar pattern in European innovation funding. The EIC receives more high quality, investable deep tech proposals than the programme can fund. The Seal of Excellence is a mechanism to make the evaluation work product useful beyond the EIC's own budget constraints.

What the Seal of Excellence is and what it does

Seal of Excellence meaning and purpose:The Seal of Excellence is a quality label awarded to proposals submitted to the EIC Accelerator and the EIC Transition mechanism that satisfy the selection criteria but cannot be funded due to budget limits. It formally recognises that a proposal has passed the Horizon Europe evaluation process and met the EIC’s quality standards. The label is meant to help recipients secure alternative forms of finance by signalling independent expert endorsement.
How the Seal is awarded:The jury responsible for evaluating applicants decides during the selection process whether a proposal that meets all criteria but falls outside the available budget should receive a Seal. In practice the certificate is issued when applicants receive their evaluation results.
What the Seal contains and how it is secured:The Seal includes basic information about the proposal, the call and the submitting organisation. It displays political endorsement with the signatures of the Commissioners in charge of innovation and regional policy. The certificate and associated documents can be digitally protected to reduce fraud and to preserve the integrity of the evaluation summary.
FeatureDetailPractical note
Who can receive itStartups and SMEs whose proposals met selection criteria for EIC Accelerator or EIC Transition but could not be funded due to budget constraintsRecipients usually receive the Seal with their evaluation results
PurposeSignal independent expert endorsement and help secure alternative fundingDoes not provide direct funding
SecurityDigitally sealed certificate and protected evaluation summary reportIntended to prevent fraud but does not guarantee funder acceptance
Number issued160 (March 2022 cut-off); 302 under Horizon Europe overall as reportedShows scale of supply of quality proposals relative to available funding

How recipients can use the Seal and practical advice

The EIC suggests that Seal holders share their supporting documentation, including the Seal certificate, full proposal and the evaluation summary report, with potential funders. The Seal acts as a trusted external assessment so public funds, regional schemes and private investors can take advantage of the Horizon Europe evaluation work. The EIC recommends diversification of funding sources and, where appropriate, combining grants with financial instruments such as loans or equity investments.

Consent and data sharing:Applicants must give prior consent for the EIC and EISMEA to share basic contact information with trustworthy alternative funders. That consent is required before any contact data is disclosed to national, regional or private funding partners.

Actors and processes behind the Seal

Multiple EU actors take part in the evaluation and post-evaluation activities. The EIC Accelerator and EIC Transition schemes operate under Horizon Europe and are implemented by the European Innovation Council and SMEs Executive Agency, known as EISMEA. Independent experts drawn from the Horizon Europe experts database act as evaluators, coaches and jury members. Additional ecosystem partners such as National Contact Points, the Enterprise Europe Network and regional managing authorities may be involved if the applicant consents to information sharing.

EISMEA and the EIC Fund role:EISMEA manages the EIC programmes and issues evaluation results and Seals. The EIC Fund handles the investment component for Accelerator awards where equity or blended finance is involved. Other organisations such as the European Investment Bank and contracted service providers may take part in due diligence and investment matchmaking when an investment component is applicable.

Selection and limits

The Seal highlights a structural challenge. The EIC’s selection process identifies more investable and high quality proposals than the programme can fund with available budgets. Labeling those proposals helps put them in front of other funders. However the label does not remove the underlying constraint. Whether a project obtains financing afterwards depends on market interest, the project’s readiness and many local and private funding conditions.

Critical caveats and what to watch for

The Seal is a useful intermediary tool but it is not a guarantee of future funding. Independent evaluation quality matters, but investors and public funders will still conduct their own due diligence. The Seal helps reduce duplication of evaluation effort but it does not replace legal, financial or technical checks required by investors. Claiming the Seal should be part of a broader strategy that includes a realistic appraisal of commercial risk and a diversified funding approach.

Limitations of the label:A Seal documents that a proposal met selection thresholds set by EIC evaluators at a given cut-off. It does not mean the project had the same ranking as funded projects nor that it met any future investor requirements such as traction metrics, customer contracts or IP freedom to operate. It is also limited by the quality of the underlying evaluation and by the evolving nature of technology and markets.

Practical checklist for Seal holders

ActionWhy it mattersHow to do it
Share evaluation summary and full proposalProvides trusted independent assessment to potential fundersInclude the digitally sealed evaluation summary with outreach to regional funds and investors
Get consent for data sharingAllows EISMEA to introduce you to alternative funders and networksOpt in when prompted to permit sharing with NCPs, EEN or regional authorities
Diversify funding sourcesReduces dependence on a single programmeApproach public regional funds, national schemes, equity investors and blended finance
Combine grants and financial instrumentsCan unlock bridge finance or co-investmentExplore loans, convertible notes or co-investment with EIC Fund partners
Use available EIC support servicesImproves readiness and investor messagingRequest business coaching or other EIC acceleration services where available

Numbers and final context

The July 2022 announcement covered 160 Seals for the March 2022 cut-off. The EIC also reported that under Horizon Europe it has issued 302 Seals of Excellence in total. Those figures underline both the scale of unmet demand for EU-backed deep tech support and the EIC’s attempt to make its evaluation output reusable across the European innovation ecosystem.

For applicants, the Seal is a useful instrument but one that must be deployed strategically. For policymakers, the number of Seals highlights the persistent gap between high quality innovation proposals and the finite public budgets available to support them. For funders, the Seal offers a convenient signal but not a substitute for their own risk assessment and legal safeguards.

Where to find more information

Companies and stakeholders can find details on the EIC website and through EISMEA channels. The Seal is normally issued alongside the evaluation summary report. Applicants should read carefully the consent and data sharing options if they want the Agency to share contact information with national or regional funding bodies or trusted private investors.